You thought I was going off on a tangent but NOT REALLY! Today we talk about that very man, the man of unmatched skills in deduction, Mr. Sherlock Holmes!
In Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective, you DON'T play as the man himself, but another dashingly handsome and cunning detective that may or may not be so good at his job. It is a co-op game that you can play with a group of your friends or by yourself. The game says you can play up to 8 people, but in my opinion, the MORE people, the better. You'll need the brain power. In my case, I should never be a consulting detective because I am REALLY NOT good at this game.
The game comes with 10 cases for the players to solve within a certain amount of leads. The game starts out with a premise, a story in which the main dilemma of the case is presented to the players. With that original story, the players must work together to come up with an idea of what happened, who killed who, or who stole what, and HOW which is all listed in the goals to win at the end of the case booklet. The game comes with a few very detailed and awesome components that make the game really draw you into the story. Players have access to newspapers from the day of the case, a book of directory for London, and a map of London to aid them in their perilous quest to find answers to the dastardly difficult case.
With their arsenal of endless amount of information in front of them, the investigators (players) set out following leads given to them in the opening story. They can first go to the crime scene, or the house of their suspect, or the victim's family member, or even to Sherlock Holmes if you have absolutely NO idea where to begin. Once you FINISH, if you can finish, you check to see if your answers are correct. There are multiple questions and you have to get them ALL right. Or else you're not doing that great of a job as a detective now are ya? Most likely, Sherlock Holmes solved the case in FAR less leads than you. And you'll end up cursing at yourself for missing such simple things that led Sherlock Holmes to solve the case far quicker than you.
******
Summary:
In the end, when everyone leans back as the case is solved, and feel like all of you need to go out for some smoke from the stress of solving the puzzle, you realize that this game has absolutely no element of luck, and you finished the case through the power of either your own or combined effort of the investigating team's gray-matter. This game requires a LOT of reading, but it has absolutely no luck factor in it at all. The game proceeds as people carefully read every sentence and every word carefully as to not miss anything and then find the next lead from that passage you just read. For me, it felt like I was taking the critical reading section of the SAT's all over again. I'm not into reading, I want to feel the rush and thrill of gambling, the intense suspense of the dice roll. Be prepared, to sit down and think and deduct for a few hours when you set up this game. To solve mysteries that are specifically assigned to Sherlock Holmes is a great task.
******
******
Recommendations:
- If you love mysteries and reading them, this game is totally for you
- There is absolutely no luck element and everyone must wrack their brain to solve these mysteris
- If you're not really into reading, this is NOT for you. There is a TON of reading in this game, and not a lot of pictures.
- Be prepared to commit several hours into this game for each case. Reading takes time and thinking takes more time.
- Because the cases are pre-made, there is very near to none replay value for the owner of this game, or for those who have seen the answers for the cases.
- Even though there's not much replay value, you will play it long enough to make it worth the buy if you're into solving mysteries that take hours and MUCH reading.




